The Council sold land to Stewart Milne Group (SMG) in 2004 for £365,000 and negotiated terms entitling it a share of any profits SMG made on the land.
There were three circumstances which would trigger payment of a proportion of the profits: if SMG bought out the Council's rights to the profit share; if SMG leased the property to a third party for more than 25 years; and if SMG sold the property to a third party.
In 2006 when SMG sold the land to a subsidiary for £483,020 it said that as certain pre-agreed costs were to be deducted from the price paid by the subsidiary and this resulted in a loss to SMG, no profit was realised and no additional payment was due to the Council.
Although not expressly provided for in the property contract, Aberdeen City Council argued that the intention of the profit share provision in the event of sale required SMG to calculate whether it had to pay a share of profits based on the "open market valuation" of the land at the time of sale rather than on the basis of the "gross sale proceeds" but SMG disagreed. The Court of Session in Scotland sided with the Council and SMG lost its appeal against that ruling at the Supreme Court on Wednesday.
The Supreme Court ruled that the "context" of the terms set out in the contract between the disputing parties had meant that SMG should have assessed the Council's entitlement to a share of the re-sale profits based on an open market valuation of the land.
"The context shows that the intention of the parties must be taken to have been that the base figure for the calculation of the uplift was to be the open market value of the subjects at the date of the event that triggered the obligation. In other words, it can be assumed that this is what the parties would have said if they had been asked about it at the time when the missives were entered into," the Supreme Court ruled . (13-page / 52KB PDF)
"The fact that this makes good commercial sense is simply a makeweight. The words of the contract itself tell us that this must be taken to have been what they had in mind when they entered into it," it said. "The only question is whether effect can be given to this unspoken intention without undue violence to the words they actually used in their agreement. For the reasons I have given, I would hold that the words which they used do not prevent its being given effect in the way I have indicated.
The Council sold land to Stewart Milne Group (SMG) in 2004 for £365000 and negotiated terms entitling it a share of any profits SMG made on the land. There were three circumstances which would trigger payment of a proportion of the profits: if SMG
Pennsylvania-based SMG, formerly known as Spectacor Management Group, currently manages the convention center and is planning to replant the Terrace Theater plaza with a tropical palm tree garden for use as additional space during receptions and an
Sindh police on Monday claimed to have arrested 12 notorious criminals in separate encounters at various parts of the metropolis and recovered huge cache of weapons from them. According to officials, a team headed by SSP Farooq Awan raided at Chinasar

Similar to an SMG, it quickly rips through foes and offers a decent amount of "rounds" per clip. With more sinister enemy types -- such as ones that continue to split into smaller and faster beings -- having a weapon that can spray a lot of ammo
They came with sophisticated and heavy weaponry including GPMG's, SMG's and bombs but our soldiers subdued them. “We had information that the Boko Haram sect planned to cause mayhem this festive period; we have put in place measures to nip this plan in
This site contains information on legal 1919 semi- and full-auto firearms. The information in these web pages is not intended to be used to construct illegal devices, nor is it intended to be viewed by minors. All NFA rules apply. Copyright 1999-2010 1919A4.com. No reproduction without permission. The opinions on this forum are those of the poster, not of management or administration. We are protected by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.